Lekh Lekha – ºÚÁϲ»´òìÈ Theological Seminary Inspiring the ºÚÁϲ»´òìÈ World Wed, 28 Oct 2026 13:52:24 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.5 Claire Bruder – Senior Sermon (RS ’27) /torah/claire-bruder-senior-sermon-rs-27/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=claire-bruder-senior-sermon-rs-27 Wed, 28 Oct 2026 13:52:23 +0000 /?post_type=post_torah&p=34303

Lekh Lekha

All Class of 2027 Senior Sermons

]]>
A Parent’s Prayer /torah/a-parents-prayer/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=a-parents-prayer Tue, 20 Oct 2026 13:19:18 +0000 /?post_type=post_torah&p=34234 When we think about Abraham and prayer, we might immediately recall the patriarch’s bold petition to God on behalf of Sodom and Gomorrah. We might even think of God telling King Abimelech that Abraham is a navi, a prophet, and thus has the special capacity to pray on the king’s behalf. Yet Abraham emerges as a person of prayer even earlier in his story. Following years of his wife Sarah’s infertility, and the birth of Ishmael to Abraham and Sarah’s slave Hagar, Parashat Lekh Lekha narrates the Divine promise to Abraham that Sarah will finally give birth. But instead of expressing joyous gratitude to God, Abraham responds: לוּ יִשְׁמָעֵאל יִחְיֶה לְפָנֶיךָ —“If only Ishmael could live before you!” (Gen. 17:18).

Abraham’s plea to God uses only four words in Hebrew, and they seem fairly straightforward. But many commentaries and translations have understood the prayer idiomatically, suggesting that Abraham requests something beyond Ishmael literally remaining alive: that Ishmael live in God’s favor (NJPS), with God’s blessing (NIV), or with divine protection (Shadal); that he live with fear of God (Rashi); that his descendants remain established forever (Nahmanides). Abraham’s plea may seem straightforward, but the many different interpretations of his words point to something less simple.

I would like to suggest three possible readings of Abraham’s prayer, including one reading that understands it literally, and two possible idiomatic readings. These different readings hinge on how we interpret the single word יִחְיֶה “will live” in the prayer. The adage goes: two Jews, three opinions. In this spirit, I offer one word, three readings.

Let’s start with a literal reading of Abraham’s plea that Ishmael “live before” God: that is, that Ishmael live and not die. The problem, of course, is that in Genesis 17, Ishmael does not appear to face a threat to his life that would call for such a reaction. In fact, Ishmael receives no mention at all in this chapter before Abraham’s prayer. The promise of a son to Sarah would surely have implications for Ishmael’s future, but it does not amount to a threat to end his life.

In next week’s parashah, on the other hand, Ishmael experiences precisely such a life-threatening scenario. When Sarah orders Abraham to banish Hagar and Ishmael and God encourages Abraham to do what Sarah says, Abraham does not stop and pray to God. Instead, Abraham sends them away with limited provisions. As the banished pair wander in the wilderness, Ishmael’s water runs out and his desperate mother awaits his death and cries. Immediately, God reacts—not to Hagar’s crying, but to the boy’s previously unmentioned crying—and the boy lives.

There is a sense in this story that a key detail is missing. How does Hagar’s crying lead to God hearing her son? The midrashic work Pirqe DeRabbi Eliezer fills in this gap, imagining Ishmael praying that God grant him death rather than allow him to die of thirst. Like the midrash, we might also attempt to reconstruct how Hagar’s crying leads to God noticing her son’s previously unmentioned cries. Imagine: perhaps Hagar prayed as she cried, leading God to pay attention to her son. And what ready-made biblical prayer would better suit the painful circumstances than “if only Ishmael could live before you!”? 

I suggest we notice how much more sense it would make for Hagar to have uttered this prayer while Ishmael is dying, than for Abraham to have spoken it when Ishmael’s life is not at stake. A literal prayer for Ishmael’s life does fit a biblical story, but not this one. Instead, we ought to seek an idiomatic alternative. I’d like to suggest two possibilities.  

First: In the Tanakh and in texts in Aramaic, Hittite, and Akkadian, scholars have identified a common ancient idiom involving pairs of words meaning “to keep alive” and “to kill,” where “killing” refers to execution and “keeping alive” refers to “pardon” or “remission of punishment.” In light of this idiom, we might understand Abraham’s prayer as follows: “If only Ishmael could receive pardon before you!” In this reading, “before you” (i.e., before God) reflects the sense that from Abraham’s perspective, Ishmael stands in judgment before God, who has judged him unfavorably. Within this context of divine judgment, Abraham appeals to God to invoke divine prerogative and grant Ishmael a pardon. The full scope of what this pardon entails emerges in the continuation of the passage, as God promises an impressive legacy to Ishmael, but excludes him from the covenant. To pardon Ishmael fully would have meant to include him as a covenant partner, but God does not agree to this. Abraham, who later prays to God to remit the punishment of Sodom and Gomorrah and then of King Abimelech, might be understood as first acting in this capacity on behalf of his rejected son.

We might also consider a second idiomatic understanding of the request for Ishmael’s “life”: In Biblical Hebrew and in Akkadian, words meaning “to live” also occur in contexts relating to adoption. At the beginning of Parashat Lekh Lekha, the surrogacy arrangement between Hagar, Sarah (Sarai), and Abraham (Abram) could have led to Sarah adopting Ishmael as her own. But this is not what happens. Sarah never accepts Ishmael as her own child and eventually drives Abraham to expel him from the household altogether. In Genesis 17, Ishmael is a child who has been rejected both by Sarah, his would-be adoptive mother, and by God, who has not chosen him as covenant partner. Elsewhere in the Tanakh, covenants are metaphorized as adoptive relationships between God as parent and Israel as child and between God as parent and the king of Israel as child. Abraham prays to God to let Ishmael “live”: that is, to let him be adopted, fully accepted, whether he means as Sarah’s child or as God’s covenant partner. But whichever Abraham prays for, the prayer does not lead to a change in Ishmael’s status.

Abraham develops as a person of prayer, so much so that the rabbis consider Abraham the founder of Tefillat Shaharit, the morning service that Jews recite daily (Berakhot 26b). While Abraham’s lengthy plea for Sodom and Gomorrah truly seals his reputation, we can also look to his earlier prayer for Ishmael. This prayer uses only four words, yet these four words burst with meaning. It is perhaps no coincidence that the rabbis also praise Abraham for “saying little, but doing much” (Tanhuma Vayera 4). As we choose our own words of prayer and recite those of our ancestors, we might reflect upon how very much meaning each of our words may hold, and how closely we may stand in relationship with God, even when our words are few.

The publication and distribution of the JTS Commentary are made possible by a generous grant from Rita Dee (³ú”l) and Harold Hassenfeld (³ú”l). 

]]>
Sara Birnbaum – Senior Sermon (RS ’26) /torah/sara-birnbaum-senior-sermon-rs-26/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=sara-birnbaum-senior-sermon-rs-26 Wed, 05 Nov 2025 13:51:31 +0000 /?post_type=post_torah&p=31005

Lekh Lekha

All Class of 2026 Senior Sermons

]]>
Claiming Our Ancestors: The Case of Terah /torah/claiming-our-ancestors-the-case-of-terah-2/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=claiming-our-ancestors-the-case-of-terah-2 Tue, 28 Oct 2025 21:01:44 +0000 /?post_type=post_torah&p=30884 For all of us, there is no going without leaving; and so it was for Abraham: “Go forth from your land, your birthplace, and the house of your father to the land that I shall show you” () [emphasis added]. And when we leave places, we leave people as well. When Abraham departed for Canaan he left behind, among others, his father Terah. And it was always thus: “Therefore shall a man leave his father and mother” (2:24).

But the Rabbis do not let go of Terah so easily. Terah is, after all, a father, who deserves his son’s honor and reverence. And for our Sages, honor and reverence are not vague and ephemeral notions; they embody concrete obligations: “What is reverence and what is honor? Reverence: a son may not stand in the place where his father customarily stands nor sit in his father’s designated seat. He may not contradict his father or side with others against him. Honor: one is obligated to provide food, drink, clothing, shelter and transportation for one’s parents” (). And if you think that these obligations can be fulfilled merely, or even mainly, by sending one’s parents a check to cover expenses you are wrong. Indeed, the Babylonian Talmud concludes that parents bear primary financial responsibility for providing for their own needs. The essence of honoring one’s parents is personal service. To put it in contemporary terms, I may not be obligated to pay for my parents’ groceries, but I am obligated to take them shopping. And this is true not only if they are incapable of shopping on their own. There are numerous stories in the Talmud of sages who honor their parents by bringing them water to drink. Perhaps in some of these cases this meant drawing water from a cistern, an arduous or at least inconvenient task. In others, however, the rabbi was performing a task that could have been done with ease by the parent—and that was the point. It is when we provide our parents with service and attention that are not essential from a utilitarian perspective that we honor them most.

The issue of Abraham’s filial obligations to Terah arises in a midrashic discussion of a textual anomaly (Midrash Aggadah to ). The Torah reports Terah’s death () before relating Abraham’s departure from Haran (12:5), leaving us with the impression that this was the chronological order of events. However, the Torah records earlier that Terah fathered Abraham when he was 70 (11:26) and that he passed away at the ripe old age of 210 (11:32). Abraham left for Canaan when he was 75 (12:4). Thus, Terah lived for 65 more years after Abraham’s departure.

As is often the case, this textual anomaly is explained by means of addressing yet another oddity. Terah is the last to be mentioned in a genealogical list that begins with Noah’s son Shem. For each of those listed, we are given the age at which he fathered his son, the next link in the genealogical chain, and the number of years he lived after fathering him. The Torah does not provide a death notice for any of these figures except for Terah: “Terah died in Haran” (). Why is Terah the exception? The midrash explains, “This teaches you that the wicked are considered as dead even during their lifetimes”—a notion expressed frequently in rabbinic midrash and therefore neither original nor surprising. By this the midrash means to say that, although Terah lived on after Abraham’s departure, the Torah considers him to have been already dead because he was spiritually moribund.

The midrash continues: “Abraham was afraid that he would be the cause of God’s name being profaned; people would say that he abandoned his father in his old age and departed. God therefore reassured Abraham, saying, ‘I exempt you from the obligation to honor your parents; moreover in the Torah I will record your father’s death before your departure.”

From the conclusion of the midrash we realize that, as is often the case, the midrash is bothered by the content of the text as well as by its form. It puts in Abraham’s mouth a question that apparently bothered the Rabbis themselves: how could the pious Abraham abandon his father rather than being a dutiful son? The midrash addresses both the textual and religious difficulties as follows: Terah’s death notice teaches us that he was wicked and therefore considered dead in his own lifetime. This notice precedes the story of Abraham to indicate that, because of Terah’s wickedness, Abraham was not obligated to stay in Haran and attend to him. The achronological mention of Terah’s death serves a second function as well. While the faithful might accept Terah’s wickedness as justification for Abraham’s actions, the doubters would see this explanation as a convenient excuse. Therefore, God denies them the opportunity to mock Abraham by concealing the fact that Terah was in fact alive when Abraham left Haran.

I assumed above that the problem of Abraham’s inattention to Terah was raised because it was a source of genuine discomfort. However, it is also possible that the issue was raised merely because it offered a pretext both to provide an ingenious explanation of two textual anomalies, and to proclaim yet again that a life of sin is a life wasted. I would like to believe that the question was asked with some degree of sincerity. It must be admitted, however, that the initial rabbinic concern for Terah as a father is far outweighed by condemnation.

If indeed the midrash reflects a genuine concern for Terah’s honor, perhaps it was inspired by a passage in Joshua’s farewell speech, part of which was incorporated into the Haggadah: “In days past your forefathers—Terah, father of Abraham and father of Nahor—lived beyond the Euphrates and worshipped other gods. But I took your father Abraham from beyond the Euphrates and Ied him through the whole land of Canaan” (). Verse 2 looks back at Abraham’s past, in which Terah appears as the father of both Abraham and Nahor. In verse 3, God plucks Abraham from both his geographical location and his religious and cultural environment, allowing Abraham to enter into a covenant with the One God, the God who will become Israel’s savior. For Abraham and his descendants, history begins anew; now only he, and not Terah, is “your father.”

And yet in verse 2 Terah is described not only as Abraham’s father, but as father of Abraham’s descendants as well—unlike the midrash, which ultimately strips Terah of his patriarchal status entirely. Verses 2 and 3 can be seen as a sort of palimpsest. This term refers to parchment or paper on which a text is written over a previous one that is still partially visible, if only faintly. The original text may no longer be legible. Nonetheless, its presence is felt, and we know that at one time these were the only words inscribed here.

Surely Joshua mentions Terah the idolater primarily as a foil in order to dramatize and emphasize the transformative consequences of God’s choosing Abraham. But the fact remains that Joshua does not ignore Terah or exclude him from Israel’s past. Abraham had a father and a home; without Terah there would have been no Abraham. We may have rejected Terah’s idolatrous ways, but we must not deny his paternity.

I imagine Terah seeing off his son. Did he understand and accept Abraham’s decision to heed a voice that only he heard? Was he thinking of the moments of joy that he had shared with his son? Was he angry, or perhaps deeply sad? I do not know. But I also wonder whether in that moment Abraham turned to his father, embraced him and said, “Wherever I go, whatever I do, you will be with me. I follow a God that is not yours and go to a faraway land, but I will never forget your kindness and care. Know that in embracing another faith I still value what you have taught me through your words and actions. Know also that you will not be forgotten; I will tell my children and grandchildren that you are my father and therefore theirs as well.”

There is no going without leaving. But it is for us to choose what we take with us.

This commentary was originally published in 2014.

The publication and distribution of the JTS Torah Commentary are made possible by a generous grant from Rita Dee and Harold (³ú”l) Hassenfeld.

]]>
Sass Brown – Senior Sermon (RS ’25) /torah/sass-brown-senior-sermon-rs-25/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=sass-brown-senior-sermon-rs-25 Thu, 07 Nov 2024 21:50:00 +0000 /?post_type=post_torah&p=28103

Lekh Lekha

All Class of 2025 Senior Sermons

]]>
How Can We Be a Blessing? /torah/how-can-we-be-a-blessing/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=how-can-we-be-a-blessing Tue, 05 Nov 2024 21:59:42 +0000 /?post_type=post_torah&p=28066 I have often pondered the meaning of the expression that a deceased person’s memory should be a blessing or will be for a blessing. Proverbs 10:7 teaches that “the name of a righteous person is invoked in blessing”—זֵ֣כֶר צַ֭דִּיק לִבְרָכָ֑ה . Originally, this likely referred to invoking the name of a well-known righteous person as an exemplar and conduit for our own blessing. The Babylonian Talmud also teaches (Kiddushin 31b) that after the death of a parent, we may continue to fulfill the mitzvah of honoring our parents, and by extension other beloved relatives and friends, by saying “zikhronam livrakhah,” “may their memory be for a blessing.”

Can only the deceased be a source of blessing? What about the living? This theme is paramount in Parashat Lekh Lekha, where God’s response to our patriarch Abraham’s call is replete with mentions of blessing. In Genesis 12:2, God says to Avram:

וְאֶֽעֶשְׂךָ֙ לְג֣וֹי גָּד֔וֹל וַאֲבָ֣רֶכְךָ֔ וַאֲגַדְּלָ֖ה שְׁמֶ֑ךָ וֶהְיֵ֖ה בְּרָכָֽה׃

I will make of you a great nation,
And I will bless you;
I will make your name great,
And you shall be a blessing.

It is easier to conceptualize what it might mean for God to bless Abraham. But what does it mean for Abraham to “be” a blessing? How might we follow in Abraham’s footsteps to be a blessing: for ourselves, our families, our communities and our world?

The 15th-century Italian commentator Ovadia Seforno offers a striking possibility: being a blessing indicates that God will rejoice in Abraham’s actions. Seforno cites a fantastical scene in the Babylonian Talmud (Berakhot 7a) in which Rabbi Yishmael ben Elisha, a High Priest, enters the Holy of Holies on Yom Kippur and encounters the Holy Blessed One, enthroned. God demands, “Yishmael, bless me!” Stunned, the High Priest blesses God:

May it be Your will that Your compassion overcome Your anger, 
and may Your compassion prevail over Your other attributes, 
and may You act toward Your children with the attribute of compassion, 
and may You enter before them beyond the letter of the law.

Whether or not this gorgeous prayer was spontaneously crafted by Rabbi Yishmael ben Elisha, the Talmud gleans the lesson that שֶׁלֹּא תְּהֵא בִּרְכַּת הֶדְיוֹט קַלָּה בְּעֵינֶיך one should not take the blessing of an ordinary person lightly. God nods in approval and acceptance of the prayer. If a mere mortal can deliver a blessing directly to God, surely people can serve as blessings to one another!

What was it about Abraham that enabled him to be a blessing? I’d argue that it was his sense of purpose. Maimonides posits that even from a young age, Abraham knew he had a purpose. In his Mishneh Torah, Maimonides explains how Abraham became a spokesperson for monotheism: “As soon as Abraham was weaned—even in his infancy—he began to muse, night and day, wondering: how is it possible that the world should be continuously in motion without one to guide it? And such were his ponderings, until he knew that there was one God.”[1] This text recalls a sweet image of baby Avram, the philosopher. It teaches us that even from a young age, Abraham knew what he was meant to do.

Having a purpose is not only important on our better days. The Austrian psychologist, philosopher, and Holocaust survivor Victor Frankl was one of the first psychologists to propose that having a high-level belief system, such as a purpose in life, enables people to endure life’s most severe and unimaginable hardships.

An article published in 2009 in the Journal of Positive Psychology[2] examined the connection between purpose and life satisfaction among adolescents, emerging adults and adults. The results of this study revealed that having identified a purpose was associated with greater life satisfaction at all those three stages of life. Interestingly, the study also found that searching for a purpose was only associated with increased life satisfaction during adolescence and emerging adulthood. Moreover, the study stated that a strong sense of purpose underscores moral action and civic engagement. We can understand from this research that both seeking and finding our purpose not only brings us contentment; it also helps us make a difference in our world.

Perhaps Abraham did not have to search for his purpose. Maybe, as Maimonides suggests, God’s call made it clear to our forefather that he was put on earth to disseminate monotheism. In contrast to our patriarch, most of us lack that kind of clarity of purpose. But in these murky and formidable times, discerning, connecting with, and taking action to realize our purpose is more important than ever.

In her Rosh Hashanah sermon, Rabbi Annie Tucker from Temple Israel Center in White Plains, New York, taught, “Purpose can pull us out of the pits of despair, motivate us to fight against improbable odds, and even lead us to risk the things most precious for the sake of something greater. It is the anchor by which we pull ourselves towards a brighter future.” Rabbi Tucker’s words imply that unfortunately given our current circumstances, our “brighter future” surely will not arrive unless we connect with our purpose and engage actively with leading ourselves—and others along with us—toward it.

If this feels like a tall order. or if you are not sure where to begin, let’s return to two messages from the Talmudic passage above: first, that “one should not take the blessing of an ordinary person lightly.” While we may not know whether God is nodding along with our prayers as the Talmud describes, I still believe that our prayers in this current moment make a difference. And second, to echo the prayer of Rabbi Yishmael ben Elisha, extending mercy and compassion toward ourselves and others, while simultaneously aspiring to go above and beyond in all that we do, is more than enough. In these ways, may we all become blessings.

The publication and distribution of the JTS Commentary are made possible by a generous grant from Rita Dee (³ú”l) and Harold Hassenfeld (³ú”l). 


[1] הלכות עבודה זרה וחוקות הגויים 1:3

[2] Cotton Bronk, K., Hill, P. L., Lapsley, D. K., Talib, T. L., & Finch, H. (2009). Purpose, hope, and life satisfaction in three age groups. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 4(6), 500–510.

]]>
Gisel Baler – Senior Sermon (RS ’24) /torah/gisel-baler-senior-sermon/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=gisel-baler-senior-sermon Tue, 14 Nov 2023 22:45:04 +0000 /?post_type=post_torah&p=24470

Parshat Lekh Lekha

All the Class of 2024 Senior Sermons

]]>
What Should We Call Our First Foremother? /torah/what-should-we-call-our-first-foremother/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=what-should-we-call-our-first-foremother Tue, 24 Oct 2023 23:01:07 +0000 /?post_type=post_torah&p=24269 Twice in this week’s parashah our first foremother’s name is disrupted. First, when she is abducted into Pharaoh’s household in Egypt, she seems to lose her name entirely. Then, in the concluding chapter, God changes her name while she is off-screen. In both moments of unnaming, Sarai is voiceless. In both, Avraham receives something grand—a gift, a covenant—while Sarai is elsewhere. Given how similar these two events are for Sarai, it feels like they are asking to be compared. On the other hand, one is an interpersonal episode of a woman suffering while her husband thrives, and the other is the initiation of Avraham’s covenant. Can the mistakes Avraham made in Egypt shed light on the holy charge he receives in the conclusion of Parashat Lekh Lekha? 

After fleeing to Egypt due to the famine in Canaan, Avraham asks his wife Sarai to masquerade as his sister. He is afraid he will be killed on account of being married to a beautiful woman. The masquerade happens without record of Sarai’s verbal consent. Avraham remains unharmed, while Sarai is abducted and married to the Pharaoh against her will. The Torah is very clear—because of her, “things went well for Avraham” (Gen. 12:16). While she is taken into Pharaoh’s house, he is lavished with rich gifts. 

Many of our commentators try to “fix” this story by insisting Sarai was not harmed during her abduction. Only Ramban comes anywhere close to acknowledging Sarai’s pain and Avraham’s complicity. On Genesis 12:10 he writes:  

Know that Avraham our father sinned a great sin, unintentionally, when he brought his wife, the tzadeket (righteous person), to a stumbling block of sin out of his own fear that [the Egyptians] would kill him. He should have had faith that God would save him . . . On account of this deed, the exile in Egypt at the hands of Pharaoh was decreed for Avraham’s descendants. 

 Ramban finishes this comment with a thematic conclusion from a verse in Ecclesiastes (3:16): “‘In the place of justice there is evil and sin.” Many of the later commentators take issue with Ramban’s choice to blame Avraham for our ancestors’ enslavement. 

As Ramban and the rest of our commentators argue over whether Avraham sinned, Sarai remains silent. In this silence, she begins to lose her name. Though the Torah often refers to women and girls without names, Sarai is an exception. She is called by her name consistently in the rest of the parashah. Somehow, Egypt is different. Of the 8 verses that describe Avraham and Sarai’s time in Egypt, Sarai is mentioned in each but called by her name in only one. For the rest, she is “his wife,” “the woman,” and “she.” In the context of the Egypt episode, the text signals Sarai’s objectification, turning her into a woman with no name at all.  

Beyond this story, names play another major role in our parashah. In Lekh Lekha’s concluding chapter God changes our ancestors’ names as the covenant and brit milah, ritual male circumcision, begin. In this final episode, our first foremother is just as silent. Physically, she is absent from the name changing encounter with God. Spiritually, she is also absent from the new covenant, which God commands will be ritualized in the blood of only Avraham and the males of the household.  

I must imagine that Sarai experienced the parallels. In both stories, she is shunted aside and unnamed while her husband receives grandeur. Still, it is only imagination. Her experience of these two moments remains untold. I am left searching for a lesson in their similarities. 

For me, a connection lies in the thematic conclusion Ramban brings from Ecclesiates 3:16: “In the place of justice there is evil, and in the place of righteousness there is evil.” Avraham and God make the same error to the same effect. They both try to create justice and righteousness, but also create wickedness. Both God and Avraham are acting in a way that, to them, seems just and righteous. Where they fail is in being unable to extend that justice and righteousness to Sarai, and to the women in her household. Avraham is acting in self-defense, but he fails to extend that defense to Sarai. God is acting to connect divine holiness to a people but fails to extend that holiness to the women. 

Because of this failure, instead of establishing a covenant that operates for both Avraham and Sarai, God establishes a patriarchy. Sarai is not present for her own name change, and the women who come after her continue to be excluded, for much longer than our exile in Egypt. Perhaps things would have been different if Sarai had reported the parallels she identified between her husband and God.  Without Sarai’s voice, it took until Ramban in the 13th century to admit Avraham made a mistake. As for God’s error—we are still in the process of admitting how much damage was done when God made this particular covenant with only the males in mind.  

In Berakhot 13a, the Talmud points out another difference between our ancestors’ name changes. Bar Kappara teaches that God commands us all to call Avraham by his new name, and Rabbi Eliezer teaches that God prohibits us from using Avraham’s old name. In contrast, according to the anonymous voice of the Gemara, Sarai gets no such commandment. Only Avraham is told to call Sarai by her new name, Sarah. Others, it seems, can continue to call her other names without violating divine desire. God changes our foremother’s name while she is absent, and we call her Sarah today. And yet, even this divine name change is unstable, perhaps not even meant for our use.  

We do not know what she thinks of Egypt, and of the covenant. We do not know what she thinks about her new name. If I could speak to her, this is what I’d want to know most. I wouldn’t ask about Egypt, about the violence some of us face along the road. I wouldn’t even ask her about being left out of the covenantal moment. She and I have learned those lessons already. Instead, I’d ask her what she wants to be called. And we’d make it a negative commandment to call her by anything else, and a positive commandment to know her name.  

The publication and distribution of the JTS Commentary are made possible by a generous grant from Rita Dee (³ú”l) and Harold Hassenfeld (³ú”l). &²Բú²õ±è;&²Բú²õ±è;&²Բú²õ±è;&²Բú²õ±è;

]]>