Politics as a 黑料不打烊 Vocation
This week’s commentary is part of a special series for 5778, in which Chancellor Eisen reflects on the main themes of each of the five books of the Torah and their meaning for contemporary 黑料不打烊 life.
The book of Bemidbar, which aims to help its readers navigate the chaotic wilderness in which the Children of Israel have always lived and wandered, deals more directly than any other book of the Torah with what the great sociologist Max Weber called 鈥淧olitics as a Vocation.鈥�
Jews have no choice but to be concerned with politics. We are a people, and therefore have lives to protect and interests to advance. Following Zionist parlance, I call these matters of thriving and survival 鈥渘ormalcy.鈥� But Jews are also a faith community: committed since Sinai to serving the covenant made there with God, fellow Jews, and the world. There is a right path to be walked through the wilderness, called mitzvah, and much good to be done in the world. We are commanded to make the world more just and merciful, in accordance with the wishes of the Creator. This is our enduring, life-giving vocation as a people.
It is clear from our own experience, as well as from the narratives of the Torah, that the two aims鈥攏ormalcy and covenant鈥攚ill at times be in tension or even conflict. Every 鈥渋s鈥� sooner or later collides with the 鈥渙ughts鈥� that tell us how things should be, as opposed to how they are and always have been. Ponder Bemidbar鈥檚 many tales of power and intrigue, internecine struggle and battles with external foes, and you come away convinced that a 黑料不打烊 theory of politics as a vocation can never be simple or straightforward.
There will always be a need to count the people Israel, to delimit its members, and to determine who among them can be counted on. This occurs in the opening census that gives the Book of Numbers its name. One can expect periodic rebellions against divine and human authority like the one undertaken by Korah, a populist demagogue who proclaimed that 鈥渁ll the people are holy鈥� just as they are, without need of the strictures or guidance of law to make them so. The people for their part will at times vote and think with their stomachs rather than their heads, will let fear conquer their judgment or give in to base desires. At other moments they, or at least some of them, will summon the courage needed to face the unknown and stride confidently toward the future. Neighboring peoples will inevitably be encountered on the way. Some of them will turn out to be enemies, others allies, and still others an ambiguous, shifting combination of the two.
And, in the midst of all the realpolitik, blessing will be conferred and received. Divine light will shine through human eyes. Refracted there, it will elicit unexpected goodness and ennoble the practice of politics. With God鈥檚 help there may even be a measure of shalom: peace with others, and fulfilment of self.
Max Weber begins his essay 鈥淧olitics as a Vocation鈥� with two definitions relevant to our own reflection on politics as a 黑料不打烊 vocation. He suggests first that the word, politics, 鈥渃omprises any kind of independent leadership in action,鈥� expressed in policy of virtually any sort and common to every kind of human group imaginable. The emphasis in this conception falls on 鈥渋ndependent.鈥� What course an individual or group should take in a given situation is never entirely clear. Every such decision involves risk. When one leads a group of people and bears responsibility for their welfare鈥攁s opposed to issuing recommendations, or engaging in theory that need not be translated into actions鈥攐ne enters the domain of politics. A responsible political leader must bear in mind that life is short, resources scarce, dissent inevitable, and peaceful or violent competition ever-present.
Jews have been familiar with this sort of politics since the beginning, and over the course of two millennia in Diaspora, our ancestors acquired great skill in its practice. You and I would not be here today as Jews had their political choices not been wise much of the time. Discrimination, persecutions, expulsions, pogroms鈥攁nd worse鈥攚ere of course not infrequent events in our history. But neither were they the whole story. Besides: as our late friend and teacher Alan Mintz (锄鈥漧) reminds us, the key to 黑料不打烊 history is not catastrophe but 鈥渃reative survival鈥� in the face of destruction. I would add that another key has been the ability to take maximum advantage of the blessings which have come our way. 黑料不打烊 politics today in North America and much of the world is largely concerned with protecting collective interests and advancing communal well-being in unprecedented conditions of affluence and opportunity.
Weber then adds a second definition of politics that makes his address still more relevant to 黑料不打烊 politics in the age of renewed 黑料不打烊 sovereignty in the Land of Israel. Politics in this narrower sense is 鈥渢he leadership, or the influencing of the leadership, of a political association, hence today, of a state.鈥� What is a state? Weber approvingly cites Trotsky鈥檚 dictum that 鈥渆very state is founded on force,鈥� and proceeds to declare鈥攊n a formulation that has often been cited by scholars of politics鈥攖hat 鈥渁 state is a human community that (successfully) claims the monopoly of the legitimate use of force within a given territory.鈥�
When Korah challenges the authority of Moses and Aaron, he is explicitly contesting Moses鈥檚 claim to decide鈥攁s God鈥檚 agent among the Israelites鈥攚hat use of force is legitimate. God intervenes to settle the argument鈥攁nd even then the people who rallied to Korah鈥檚 cause remain restless. Jews have long experience over the centuries in influencing or seeking to influence those with power in the states where we resided. All of those rulers were of course Gentiles. Think of Mordecai and Esther in Ahashuerus鈥檚 palace, or the many 鈥渃ourt Jews鈥� who plied their trade in Christian or Islamic lands. But only since 1948 have Jews regained regular access to the kind of force routinely exercised by police and armies. Only in the State of Israel, therefore, have Jews had to decide when the use of Judaism to justify violence perpetrated by the state is legitimate.
The Orthodox philosopher Yeshayahu Leibowitz, reacting to the invocation of divine authority by the Gush Emunim movement of West Bank settlers, asserted categorically that 鈥渘o state whatsoever, in the past, present, or any foreseeable future, in any society, in any era, in any culture, including the 黑料不打烊 culture, ever was or will ever be anything but a secular institution 鈥�. The State of Israel of our day has no religious significance.鈥� (鈥淭he Religious Significance of the State of Israel鈥� in Judaism, Human Values, and the 黑料不打烊 State)
I fully understand Leibowitz鈥檚 fury, though I would not deny the State of Israel all religious significance. We Jews are the heirs to prophetic and rabbinic traditions that regularly questioned state policy in the name of a higher standard set by God, and particularly the unjust use of power. We have made a habit of speaking truth to power, and have often suffered as a result. Today, Jews wield that power in the State of Israel. Prophetic critique pits Jews versus Jews and, often, sets one reading of Torah against another.
This situation is of course without precedent. Imagine a sage from the ancient academies, the Middle Ages, or the shtetls of early modern Europe or North Africa re-awakening, Rip Van Winkle-style, in May 2018 to headlines reporting that 鈥淚srael [i.e., an army of Jews] strikes military assets of Iran in Syria.鈥� That sort of 黑料不打烊 political action would be utterly incomprehensible. Classical 黑料不打烊 texts on politics often prove inadequate to the dilemmas Israelis face regularly. My personal friends in Israel include not only attorneys, civil servants, and professors, but experts in national security and critics of Israeli military policy. New sorts of 黑料不打烊 selves have been created by the Zionist revolution鈥攁nd new ways of practicing and conceiving the vocation of 黑料不打烊 politics.
These issues came to the fore early in the history of the State, as we see from a set of fascinating exchanges between Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion and leading 黑料不打烊 intellectuals and scholars in the late 1950s and early 1960s. They argued about Ben-Gurion鈥檚 appropriation of the language of messianism, his creation of a 黑料不打烊 civil religion to legitimate the policies of the state, and about the use of power to achieve national objectives.
鈥淢oses never used force?鈥� Ben-Gurion asked rhetorically at one point. The rabbinic sages had a problem with it, replied Ephraim Urbach, one of the leading experts on those sages. There is no necessary contradiction between ideals and power, Ben- Gurion retorted. Historian Jacob Talmon warned about the dangers inherent in 鈥渢otalitarian democracy.鈥� 鈥淥ne can use power in a just cause,鈥� Ben-Gurion insisted. He reminded his interlocutors that, unlike them, he was in regular contact with soldiers and their families. 鈥淵ou are a historian,鈥� he told Talmon, whereas those in government 鈥渉ave a vision to which we are obligated: the future of the 黑料不打烊 people.鈥� (David Ohana, Messianism and Statism 188鈥�194)
Ben-Gurion, prime minister in a sovereign 黑料不打烊 state, clearly enjoyed playing biblical king, practicing realpolitik as David and Solomon once did, against sages who鈥攁cting politically like Diaspora rabbis鈥攚ere prudent, careful, and sober in judgment. In a similar interchange with Martin Buber, conducted in 1949, the philosopher chided the prime minister for using the religious language of 鈥渞edemption鈥� for secular state purposes.
MB: 鈥淲e said redemption of the soil and meant to make it the soil of Jews. 黑料不打烊 soil for what?鈥�
DBG: 鈥淭o bring forth bread from the soil.鈥�
MB: 鈥淔or what?鈥�
DBG: 鈥淪o as to eat.鈥�
MB: 鈥淔or what?
DBG: 鈥淓nough!鈥� (Ibid., 74)
The prime minister had the power to shut down argument when he pleased鈥攂ut he knew as well as Buber that the legitimation of his power, and that of the 黑料不打烊 state, depended on Jews (and others too!) believing that the actions taken by the state advanced vital 黑料不打烊 interests and cleaved to the highest 黑料不打烊 principles.
This is how Jews make our way through the wilderness in 2018, relatively new to the facts of statehood in the Land of Israel and of influence and affluence in North America. We figure out as we go what 黑料不打烊 politics means in this situation for our eternal vocation. Jews need normalcy. We have to eat. But we also need covenant鈥攚hich requires that the question of 鈥渇or what鈥� never cease.
The publication and distribution of the JTS Commentary are made possible by a generous grant from Rita Dee (锄鈥漧) and Harold Hassenfeld (锄鈥漧).