The Power to Choose: A Founding Moment of 黑料不打烊 Ethics
Choice 鈥� between right and wrong 鈥� is the opening theme of Parashat Re鈥檈h. 鈥淪ee (谤别鈥檈丑), I place before you (lifneikhem) today blessing and curse. Blessing 鈥� if you heed God鈥檚 commands鈥�; curse 鈥� if you do not鈥︹�� (Deut. 11:26). This verse is a portal to the end of Deuteronomy: 鈥淪ee (谤别鈥檈丑) I have placed before you (lifanekha) today life 鈥� and the good 鈥� and death 鈥� and the bad鈥� Life and death I have placed before you 鈥� blessing and curse 鈥� and you shall choose life鈥︹�� (Deut. 30:15, 19).
The Israelites stand at the precipice of entering the land (Deut. 11:29) and face the immense challenge of establishing a stable, thriving society. The dramatic shift from a nomadic society protected by God鈥檚 presence and encamped near the Tabernacle, to an expansive polity, posed profound agricultural, social, political, and religious challenges addressed in the parashah.[1]
It is significant that this foundational moment is framed by the notions of choice and decision. Good legislation is a necessary component of a thriving society 鈥� one of the primary preoccupations of Deuteronomy. But a legal system that is good 鈥� comprised of God鈥檚 commandments 鈥� is not sufficient. A guiding ethos must undergird the choice to do what is right and good. Ethics is thus a central preoccupation of Deuteronomy, as well.
If it were easy to create a stable, just, thriving society, there would be no need to emphasize choice. However, it is natural for societies to organize around scarcity, competition, and the pursuit of power for survival, as in the 鈥渟tate of nature鈥� described by political philosophers. Deuteronomy thus emphasizes that the good life 鈥� even in a well-organized society marked by an excellent legal code 鈥� must be repeatedly chosen. Dilemmas abound between competing desires, needs, and values. A broader ethical vision serves as a guide in those ever-present difficult moments of decision.
The choice presented at the beginning of Parashat Re鈥檈h is presented both in the second person singular (谤别鈥檈丑) and the second person plural (lifneikhem). R. Jacob Ben Asher (13th century) argued that the singular-plural doubling is significant (Baal Ha-Turim, Deut. 14:1). The good life requires coordination among the individual and the collective.
But what guides our choices? In addition to legislation, Deuteronomy is filled with programmatic statements that provide overarching norms to guide our choices more broadly.
For example, Deuteronomy, including this parashah (at Deut. 13:5), is the primary locus of the concept of 鈥渨alking in God鈥檚 ways鈥� (vehalakhta bidrakhav). From the Talmud to medieval and modern philosophy Imitatio Dei 鈥� imitating God 鈥� has been a central component of 黑料不打烊 ethics, emphasizing virtues and ethical acts ascribed to God in biblical narrative (e.g. Talmud B. Sotah 14a, Shabbat 133b).
Ethics is often associated with an orientation toward the other. The infinite worth of all human beings, foundational to ethics, emerges with the creation of the human being in the image of God. The image of God is also found in the self, and there is an intimate interrelationship between self-worth and the worth of all others. This interplay 鈥� between an orientation toward the other and the preservation of self-dignity 鈥� lies at the heart of 黑料不打烊 ethics.
Parashat Re鈥檈h gives unique expression to the importance of a theologically-informed fundamental sense of self-worth, at Deut. 14:1: 鈥淵ou are children of the Lord your God 鈥� you shall not cut yourselves (lo titgodedu)鈥� [in mourning] over the dead.鈥�
In Pirkei Avot, R. Akiva identifies this verse as one of three essential theological-ethical statements in the Bible (Avot 3:14).[2] The verse includes a broader value statement that results in a norm. The broader concept is the idea of being the children of God, which dignifies the 黑料不打烊 people, who must, in turn, preserve their own dignity and self-worth (R. Samson Raphael Hirsch [19th century], Commentary on the Pentateuch, Deut. 14:1). The norm is a commandment against self-harm. In moments of crisis, when one feels broken, there is a temptation to externalize and literally embody that brokenness.
In the development of 黑料不打烊 law, two distinct commandments emerged from the single statement 鈥測ou shall not cut yourselves.鈥� The first is the principle against physical harm to the body of the individual. The second, derived from rabbinic exegesis (Talmud B. Yevamot 14a), is a prohibition against dividing the body politic into polarized factions governed by separate legal courts. Polarization emerges at moments of profound crisis within the polis, where the temptation becomes great to display this brokenness by fracturing fundamental institutions 鈥� creating separate legal frameworks. R. Judah Loew (Maharal) of Prague (16th century) noted that extreme civil discord fractures the collective, and the individual citizen, too, feels 鈥渁s if鈥� their own 鈥渂ody is broken apart鈥� (Gur Aryeh on Deut. 14:1).
In Deut. 14:1, something about being God’s children is a call to the individual and the collective to remain whole, even 鈥� especially 鈥� when brokenness abounds everywhere. Being God’s children is an unconditional status (R. Meir’s position on Deut. 14:1, Talmud B. Kiddushin 36a) that implies being loved and valued always. This knowledge is central to the pursuit of the good life.
Being God鈥檚 children is always simultaneous with being created in God鈥檚 image alongside all creatures (Avot 3:14). An ethic of self-preservation is intimately intertwined with an ethic of the dignity of all. Neither can be forgone if a society and the individuals who comprise it are to have any hope of achieving the 鈥済ood life.鈥�
In Parashat Re鈥檈h, at the precipice of forming a stable and permanent civil society in the promised land, the civil and political founding is accompanied by an ethical founding. The call to self-dignity and self-preservation of Deut. 14:1 is immediately followed by a call to holiness: 鈥淔or you are a holy people unto the Lord, your God鈥︹�� (Deut. 14:2).
These verses transport the Israelites back to Leviticus 19, another founding moment of 黑料不打烊 ethics. 鈥淏e holy, for I the Lord your God am holy鈥� (Lev 19:2) is an earlier articulation of the notion of imitatio Dei 鈥� a call to a life that mimics God鈥檚 holiness. Leviticus 19 also includes the prohibition against self-harm (19:28) as well as the command to 鈥渓ove the neighbor as yourself鈥� (19:18) and its parallel command to 鈥渓ove the stranger as yourself鈥� (19:34).
Parashat Re鈥檈h opens with the rallying cry of the second half of Deuteronomy 鈥� the call to choose 鈥渢he blessing.鈥� Central to the good life is a deep sense of self-worth, self-dignity, and a commitment to self-preservation. This follows from being the beloved children of God. A thriving community also requires an ethos of the dignity of neighbor and stranger, also created in the image of God. At times of crisis, there is a temptation both to fracture the community and overlook the dignity of the other. It can feel impossible to choose the 鈥渂lessing鈥� and 鈥渢he good.鈥� The concept of choice was developed in Deuteronomy at a crucial foundational moment. At the cusp of a new life, fear of the unknown and awareness of the profound challenges that lay ahead were countered with the formulation of guiding values and a persistent belief in the power to choose.
[1] The geographical distance of a centralized Temple would pose agricultural questions about food supply and meat consumption (e.g. Deut. 12:20ff). The risk of structural poverty called for rigorously applied social policies (Deut 15:1-18). Absent the constancy of the divine presence of the wilderness, charismatic demagogues who might sway the people would need to be opposed (Deut 13:2ff).
[2] The others are Gen. 9:6 (prohibiting murder on account of the creation of the human being in the image of God), and Prov. 4:2 (declaring the Torah a good teaching not to be forsaken).